On February 20, 2020, a new draft of EU GMP Annex 1 was finally released. Robotic technology, Barrier System, rapid microbial testing and monitoring systems, single use system are the trends of pharmaceutical equipment. CCS proposed in 2017 version is even more prominent in the new draft, which was mentioned more than 40 times in the full text.
Ms. Andrea Wu - Tofflon Isolator Specialist shares her view on application of CCS into Tofflon Barrier Isolation.
What is CSS?
Contamination Control Strategy (CCS) is defined as below according to the glossary on Annex 1：
A planned set of controls for microorganisms, pyrogens and particulates, derived from current product and process understanding that assures process performance and product quality. The controls can include parameters and attributes related to active substance, excipient and drug product materials and components, facility and equipment operating conditions, in process controls, finished product specifications, and the associated methods and frequency of monitoring and control.
CCS is not a complete new concept, which can be consider as the overall risk assessment related contamination, and measures taken against containment throughout the product life cycle. As a quality management document, CCS emphasizes identification contamination risk of the facilities, equipment, utilities etc. affect CQA in the design phase. Historical data of critical parameters or records need to be reviewed, approved and evaluated for trends, as a supportive information to improvement of CCS. CCS should be continuously improved in aseptic process practice based on the QRM principles. CCS may be already required by some inspectors although Annex 1 hasn’t been official implementation.
Isolator is one of CCS for aseptic processing as we all known. Ms. Andrea Wu – Tofflon Isolator Specialist shares her view how to apply CCS into Tofflon barrier Isolation system for lyophilized injectables.
Below a list of things that need to be considered as contents of CCS related:
The Quality of the Air in the Background Environment of Isolator
The background of open isolator（e.g. filling isolator） should be designed based on risk assessment according to the latest draft of Annex 1. The factors that are usually considered for analysis are the pressure differential, materials transfer methods, operator interventions and so on. ISPE guideline (volume 3, 2018) gives some suggestion of this application, and LP/GAAS concept is given when RABS is used.
The Air Inside of Isolator
First Air coming from the HEPA is considered to protect open products or critical parts that are sterilized inside of open Isolator. The air speed need to be designed and monitored to ensure this protection. and the air visualization studies need to be done in both at rest and in options. Online environmental monitoring should be designed as one of CCS of isolator, based on the risk assessment. The sampling locations, frequency and methods need to defined in the CCS. Non-viable particles need to be continuously monitored to capture the evidence of contamination caused by all interventions, transient events and any system deterioration, the sampling location, sampling flow rate and shape of the sample pipping need to be considered. Rapid monitoring of viable method is promoted in the Annex 1 to reduce the intervention of operator compared to traditional ways to reduce the contamination caused by environment monitoring itself. Fast feedback of the viable result can tell more information in the critical area for quick action.
The Integrity of the Isolator
Glove leakage test here mentioned in the latest version of Annex 1 draft need to methodology demonstrated to be suitable for the task and criticality. The minimum test frequency is mentioned as “…., at a minimum at the beginning and end of each batch, and should include a visual inspection following any intervention that may affect the integrity of the system. For single unit batch sizes, integrity may be verified based on other criteria, such as the beginning and end of each manufacturing session… ”
Preventive measures (including material chosen, testing, cleaning/ disinfection, wear second glove and change frequency) should be listed in CCS to avoid any failure of gloves in the production.
Isolator leakage test is vaguely mentioned in this draft. ISPE guideline have the description of the leakage test methods for isolator. In CCS, the leakage rate test method and criteria should consider the pressure design and background classification and the type of isolator. For most open isolator, leakage test of isolator normally be executed before VPHP cycle. If negative pressure is used for aseptic when containment closed isolator application, it makes sense to test the leakage of isolator after one batch.
Intervention of Isolator During Production
Interventions ( both inherent and corrective) in processing should be identified in CCS in the early phase of isolator design (before Mock-UP or DQ), with “ One batch end is one batch start” in mind, avoiding any unexpected operation especially transfer during production. A list of intervention is preferred to be prepared for Mockup, and airflow visualization studies accordingly. APS should also need follow this intervention list to simulate the process.
Decontamination of Isolator
A Cleaning procedure of isolator should be one topic in CCS. The clean method should be designed based on the process. For example, containment application, where WIP or CIP will be equipped in isolator for cleaning. A suitable cleaning solution should be chosen according to the product. Rinsing process also need to specified to use WFI or purified water in certain temperature. Drying, temperature and humidity control should be also considered for following sporicidal disinfection. The key parameters of sporicidal disinfection (e.g. VPHP) should be defined in CCS and should be verified, monitored, recorded and reviewed. Dead legs should be identified. Special cleaning or manual disinfection may be required if some part or surfaces is not exposed. It is necessary to consider the elimination of moisture after the cleaning, and the temperature turbulence need to be aware affecting the disinfection effect and the repeatability of the cycle.
Andrea Wu, Vice General Manager of Shanghai Tofflon Airex Science and Technology Co., Ltd (Tofflon JV with Airex - Japanese barrier isolator technology leader). She has over 10-year experience in Barrier Isolation System relative technology including the international regulations, the system theory and design, validation of Barrier System and Decontamination.